This book has been particularly complex to me. Perhaps not complex, but simply laborious, which made it much better than I expected it to be.
Firstly, because it makes historical references formerly unknown to me, and the rich narrative. The latter is what caught me the most. I won't get into the smallest of details, for I'd not know how to manage them to be understood righteously, but I'll say, what had me thinking, and must I note before that this doesn't happen to me with everything, are the metaphysical references, or moreso analogies used in half the book, analogies to things I couldn't myself describe well, but I believe they speak for themselves.
"Yesterday's rose endures in its name; we hold empty names"
As for the time it took me to write such a small opinion, my part on this needed its delay for far more mundane reasons than I'd like to admit, thus, I'll omit them not without offering an apologise, that I owe to Chris and to our book club.
sábado, 27 de agosto de 2011
viernes, 12 de agosto de 2011
I am damned!
Do you know the difference between 14th century Christian factions? I hope you do if you've any aspirations toward reading The Name of The Rose. On the outside this is a murder mystery novel with monks. Inside is a text full of studied observations on 14th century scholars and theology. If you didn't know how a Dolcinian differed from a Minorite you will quickly learn or be swallowed whole. You will learn to love very detailed descriptions of architecture or be swallowed whole. If you can avoid being swallowed you'll read a fantastic novel.
Like I said a paragraph ago, this is only a murder mystery as a way to give the main characters plenty of time to discuss the role of the monk in society. Is he a scholar, is he a ruler, is he some hybrid of the two? Are books for the learned (the monks) only or can secular intellectuals also be allowed their knowledge. Is some knowledge too dangerous to be freely known? With all these things being discussed it's no wonder why our protagonists are so bad at solving crimes.
It's not until the end, when all the crimes are done and over that they catch up. And I want you to know that it simply doesn't matter. By that time your head will be swimming with far more important thoughts.
so go spend $10 and read it, you bum.
Like I said a paragraph ago, this is only a murder mystery as a way to give the main characters plenty of time to discuss the role of the monk in society. Is he a scholar, is he a ruler, is he some hybrid of the two? Are books for the learned (the monks) only or can secular intellectuals also be allowed their knowledge. Is some knowledge too dangerous to be freely known? With all these things being discussed it's no wonder why our protagonists are so bad at solving crimes.
It's not until the end, when all the crimes are done and over that they catch up. And I want you to know that it simply doesn't matter. By that time your head will be swimming with far more important thoughts.
so go spend $10 and read it, you bum.
martes, 9 de agosto de 2011
post-conclusions with "the name of the rose"
the antichrist is behind us. like the nomads we are we've left the antichrist behind to find new land to hunt and gather on. that has brought us to the fertile plains of umberto eco's the name of the rose. and we shall eat well, my brothers and sisters. it's a much longer text than the antichrist so the updates will be less frequent but carry the hope with you that updates are indeed coming. try not to kill yourself in the meantime.
miércoles, 20 de julio de 2011
Conclusion.
I chose The Antichrist because I believe both Chris and I like the work of Nietzsche, but we had not read this one, which strikes me as the cherry on top of the cake, but in the near future I plan on furthermore studying his work, as it's not as easy as reading it once to understand it fully.
The book was beast.
The First Book. The Antichrist,
Once upon a time, yesterday, I had a lot more to say about this subject. Somehow and someway that was all lost. Now I've been tasked with bringing some of my magic back but I'm not feeling it like I was before. Rest assured, fair reader, I shall bring the fiery passion that was erased from this blog in future entries.
The Antichrist by Nietzsche, Shurik's first choice for the club. I don't know why she chose it but I'm glad she did. An essay criticizing Christianity and even more importantly, the idea of weak religions. Power is a key theme throughout. How does religion diminish power, how does religion glorify power, how does power advance man, how do we regain our lost power. Interesting, if not a whole lot silly. There is a time for power and a time for pity. That will get you much further than pure power grabs and destruction.
European imperialism is a perfect example of power gone wrong. Unless you're white, I guess.
The Antichrist by Nietzsche, Shurik's first choice for the club. I don't know why she chose it but I'm glad she did. An essay criticizing Christianity and even more importantly, the idea of weak religions. Power is a key theme throughout. How does religion diminish power, how does religion glorify power, how does power advance man, how do we regain our lost power. Interesting, if not a whole lot silly. There is a time for power and a time for pity. That will get you much further than pure power grabs and destruction.
European imperialism is a perfect example of power gone wrong. Unless you're white, I guess.
An introduction
I'm the Chris of the Shurik and Chris Book Club. As has been said before this is a club for fun reading and I'm here to ensure the fun never goes away. But I'm as devoted to intelligent discussion as my companion, Shurik. Let's get to it.
martes, 19 de julio de 2011
Shurik's Review of The Antichrist.
Christianism brought with it a series of nihilistic values, ones that go against the wildest manifestations of human nature with the premise and promise of heavenly grasp.
But neither heaven, the salvation of the soul and all that regards these absurd and more evil in its own parameters than innocent ideas, are real.
Not only does Nietzsche deny the current existence of an almighty deity, namely God, but he states that it is not necessary to have a spiritual discipline. Much on the contrary, it is counterproductive.
And only those, who understand that what we must, if anything, worship is the gift of life and human nature in its purest form, will be able to follow up to his teachings, and at the precise moment, find the path to the Übermensch, and ultimately the long-awaited final, that is man.
But neither heaven, the salvation of the soul and all that regards these absurd and more evil in its own parameters than innocent ideas, are real.
Not only does Nietzsche deny the current existence of an almighty deity, namely God, but he states that it is not necessary to have a spiritual discipline. Much on the contrary, it is counterproductive.
And only those, who understand that what we must, if anything, worship is the gift of life and human nature in its purest form, will be able to follow up to his teachings, and at the precise moment, find the path to the Übermensch, and ultimately the long-awaited final, that is man.
Suscribirse a:
Entradas (Atom)